My great grandfather, Robert Fulton Crawford, was born in Fayetteville, Tennessee in 1837, and died in Lead, South Dakota in1918. Since I was a child, I have heard tales about him and his life story has fascinated me.
THE MYTH
I must have asked a question that triggered this story the first time, but my grandma was a great story teller. As she sat knitting, she began the following tale… “Your grandpa always said his dad was born in Arkansas. When he was just a toddler, his mother was killed by her slave girl. His father was out working in the fields on Christmas morning and the girl hit her mistress over the head with a cast iron skillet. (imagine my wide eyes as a preteen). The girl left young Robert with his mother’s dead body, and they weren’t found until his dad came back from the field. The slave was hunted down, convicted and killed. Robert’s father kept the slave’s young son and raised him with Robert. Both boys grew up, went to law school and became lawyers. The slave boy became one of the first ‘black’ lawyers in America. and Robert was the first judge in Kerrville, Texas.” I was shocked and couldn’t wait to share this information with my parents. They assured me this is just family lore with grandma’s embellishments.
Another time grandma pulled out a typed story, probably written by one of my dad’s older sisters. “Robert Fulton Crawford, (named after his father’s friend Robert Fulton, inventor of the steam boat). He married and had 2 sons, Hugh and Kit. Kit became a writer and used the name of Marion Francis. Their mother died. Robert Fulton Crawford was a drummer boy in the Civil War. He was well educated, attended the University of Missouri and became a lawyer and business man, he made lots of money. He went from Texas to Kansas, saw a friend who had a beautiful daughter, 35 years his junior. Her name was Bessie Amelia Smedley. Hugh was 2 years her senior and Kit the same age. Robert and Bessie married and had 7 children: Robert Fulton jr., Paul, Earl, Jean, Pearl, Claude, and Grace. Robert Fulton lost all of his money, and moved to Spearfish and became the County Judge which he was until he was nearly 80. James Buchanan was Robert F. Jr.’s uncle. Grandpa Crawford was brilliant, had a terrible temper and totally unfair to his wife and children although the children had a great deal of respect for him.” This just heightened my curiosity and desire to chase my family roots.
his obituaries state that he attended Cumberland University of Tennessee. During the Civil War he served in the struggle under General Dick Taylor. He was the leading factor in the Cherokee Livestock Association which leased the Cherokee Strip from the government, but sold out his interest there in 1883., moving to Spearfish in the spring of 1886, where he resumed the practice of law… While in Texas and Kansas City, he was very successful in the livestock business, accumulating hundreds of thousands of dollars, until the failure of three banking houses swept away the major part of his fortune.
The MAN
Mom, the Archivist, was surprised to find some of the myth to be true, along with many other fascinating details about great grandpa Crawford.
Robert Fulton Crawford was born in Fayetteville, Tennessee in 1837. His parents were Andrew Crawford and Minerva Buchanan. The young family joined relatives in Washington County Arkansas. The story about the murder is partially true!
In History of Washington County, we found the following:
“In the year 1840 the committee officiated at another execution. This time a slave-girl, Caroline, was hung for the murder of her mistress, the wife of Andrew A. Crawford.” More details are recorded, but that is another story.
His obituary states that he attended Cumberland University in Tennessee. he was admitted to the Bar in the state of Missouri in 1860. Robert, or R.F., was a young attorney in Kerr County Texas in 1861. Feb., 1861, he joined the Texas Minutemen, and in August of 1861, he married Fannie Hudson. It is written that Robert, a young attorney, was being paid as a teacher in 1862, and he reenlisted in the Confederate army. He was appointed as the First Kerr County Attorney in March of 1867, and was removed from that position in August of 1867 by military order. The reason given is involvement in the confederacy.
Robert and Fannie had 4 children, James Hugh (1863), Richard F (1865), Etta J. (1870), Kit (1872), all born in Kerr County. The years of Reconstruction were a difficult time in Kerr County. In December, 1872, R.F. and Fanny began selling their property in Kerrville.
It is known that Robert participated in getting cattle herds to Kansas City. By 1875 he had moved his family to Kansas City, Missouri and owned Crawford and Co. Wholesale Butchers. This changed to Stock Dealer and Stock Raiser by 1880. We have found no documentation about him with the Cherokee livestock Association. In 1881, Fannie and at least 2 of their children died and are buried in Kansas City.
While still listed as a cattle dealer in Kansas City in 1883, Robert was on the move. He married Bessie Smedley, a girl 30 years his junior, and they had a son, Robert Fulton jr., born in Sherman Texas. The marriage took place in Johnson County, Kansas. Another son, Paul, was born in 1885 in Kansas City. Meanwhile, R.F. Is shown to own shares of the Carbonate mine, Carbonate, SD in 1885.
R.F. was living in Spearfish, SD in 1886, when he sold his shares of a mine in Carbonate at quite a loss. It is thought that Robert went north because of the cattle business, and his mine investments, settling in Spearfish. It is not known when Bessie and the children arrived, but the next child was born in Spearfish in 1888. We know that he is listed as an attorney and Judge (Justice of the Peace) in Spearfish, and lived there while adding 5 more children – Jean (1888), Earl (1890), Claude (1893), Pearl (1898), and Grace (1903) to the family. He was known as Judge Crawford. His daughter, Jean, brought him to her home in Lead, SD, when illness overtook him. He passed away in January, 1918, and is buried in Spearfish, SD.
What happened to the Slave’s son? Did RF help organize the Cherokee Livestock Association? Did he make hundreds of thousands of dollars, only to lose it when 3 banking houses failed? Did Kit really change his name? What happened to Kit? Still to be determined… Myth or reality?